Universal Derailleur Hanger - UDH
The history of UDH
In the past, frame maker made their own rear derailleur hangers. And often with a new frame design, they also designed a new hanger, one that fit just a little better, looked a little more integrated, etc. As a result, there are thousands of rear derailleur hangers in the world.
As you may have experienced, this is a nightmare. Whenever you break your hanger, the odds are slim that your local bike shop has exactly that hanger you need (which is why we ship a spare hanger with every frame, to make sure you're never stranded without).
Years ago, SRAM introduced the UDH (Universal Derailleur Hanger). This was a hanger that could function like any normal derailleur hanger, with the added bonus that it would rotate under big impacts so it would move your derailleur away from danger if you hit something. To use the UDH, all manufacturers had to do was build a specific hole shape into their frame, and then the UDH could bolt into that.
This was great for manufacturers, stores and consumers as they could use one derailleur for every frame (instead of all the styles that existed before) and this UDH hanger is compatible with everything. SRAM, Shimano, Campagnolo, doesn't matter. Plus it did a good job of protecting the RD in an impact.
UDH was originally a mountain bike product, and there was one more incentive SRAM used to convince frame makers. In the future, they might make product that would only work with "the UDH". That made it an easy choice for frame makers. UDH was compatible with all current drivetrains and some mystery future drivetrain, which is more than they could say of any other hanger including all the ones they had designed themselves in the past. So virtually all the MTB frames changed to UDH.
This means that SRAM controls a piece of real estate on all those MTB frames. Not only the shape and dimensions of the hole where you insert the UDH, but also the area around, as SRAM defined stay-out zones (areas where the drivetrain maker will tell frame makers to leave free, as the cassette, chain or derailleur might need to occupy that space).
This was a brilliant variation on the Trojan horse story, but in this case the Trojans (frame makers) don't suffer, it is the rival empires (other drivetrain makers) interested in trading with the Trojans that are outmaneuvered.
Transmission
When MTB frames were overwhelmingly equipped with UDH hangers, SRAM made its next move. The mystery drivetrain did not technically only work with UDH, it only worked with the hole in the frame that was needed for UDH. It called this Transmission. There has been some confusion on the terminology, so just for clarity:
- UDH is the hanger that SRAM makes available to all frame maker and which accepts all standard drivetrains
- UDH-compatible are frames with a hole and stay-out zone in the dropout that follows the specifications set by SRAM, and thus fit the UDH hanger
- Transmission is the SRAM drivetrain design that doesn't use a UDH hanger but instead it uses the hole and stay-out zone in the dropout that otherwise the UDH hanger would use. So instead of attaching the derailleur to a hanger and the hanger to the frame, the Transmission derailleur mounts directly to the frame. This is why it is also called a hangerless or direct-mount design.
Transmission for gravel
Today, SRAM introduces a Transmission groupset also for gravel but only at the highest level (Red XPLR). So while all other groupsets (Force, Rival, Apex) keep the standard rear derailleur design (compatible with any frame), Red XPLR gets Transmission and thus needs a UDH-compatible frame.
This is why as part of OPEN 12.5, all our new frames will be UDH compatible. Meaning you can build them up hangerless with Red XPLR Transmission or with any other drivetrain (SRAM, Shimano or Campagnolo) using the UDH hanger. It doesn't really change anything for the current UP or WIDE as they remain compatible with all the drivetrains we currently use (Force/Eagle, Rival, Ekar, GRX) but the new UDH-compatible frames will give people who build up their bikes from scratch the option to also spec Red XPLR.
I also wrote up a more in-depth look at Red XPLR
Hey, Ive read comments above about mind frames not being compatible with udh. What about wide? Would that take an adapter for udh? And will you consider having it in stock anytime soon? Thanks in advance
Like many people hère i would definitely appreciate an adapter for my min'd and my upper to be able to use New drive train on my current bikes without having the need to buy a New frame (yet;) You know better than anyone if it is doable or not but please consider this with a good amount of interest. Your custumer deserves this ! Best Jérôme
i understand but when it is physically not possible, that's the end of that. I know one aftermarket solution but they stopped offering it, and it only fit one frame. You just have to be lucky that the frames old frame shape isn't in the way of the new system, and with us (and many other frames) that simply isn't the case. The chain would go straight through our seat stay, obviously an issue. But we always try to come up with workarounds and alternatives, it just doesn't look good.
Would be very interested in an UDH Upgrade for my existing MIN.D
Hi Julian, unfortunately it is not possible to upgrade an existing frame to UDH, the shapes of the dropout are simply not compatible.
Won’t this affect frame manufacturers. Why would I buy a frame that then limits me to what group set I can put on it. I have changed group set for different reasons in the past. If I buy a UDH frame it sounds like me choice of group set is very limited.
Hi Steve, I think you misunderstood. A UDH-compatible frame is compatible with .... the UDH hanger. And a UDH hanger works with every drivetrain out there. Except a Transmission drivetrain, which works with the UD-compatible frame without even needing the hanger. So either you have a random frame with its proprietary hanger, which then works on every drivetrain except Transmission Or you have a UDH-compatible frame with a UDH hanger, which then works on every drivetrain including Transmission if you remove the hanger.
Any chance of a customer loyalty discount for those of us looking to upgrade?
Hi Lee, we certainly value loyalty. If that means a discount, I don't know. And and I haven't really discussed that yet
Are u guys create a piece to use UHD in the old open bikes?
Currently that doesn't seem possible but we're actually discussing this next Monday
Its always struck me as odd that the Universal Derailleur Hanger is a proprietary SRAM design. Also that SRAM Transmission is hangerless, therefore it doesn’t even use a UDH! …and no one even seems to question the lack of a sacrificial hanger in SRAM Transmission! Any broken drop outs out there? Also, surely a true UDH would work with any bike with any rear drop out. Maybe OPEN could reinvent a true UDH.
It's a whole different system so that sacrificial aspect really isn't needed. The RD isn't really attaching to the frame so much as to the rear axle. Plenty of videos out there of people jumping on their RD without any problem. And for frontal impacts, the RD swings out of the way.
New UDH frames would work with MTB Transmission, right? The Mullet setup has been what works for me where I live. Thanks for this excellent post!
Re: Red brakes - they are really great and quite the improvement over previous SRAM drop bar brake/lever combos. But you don't have to leave the mullet concept behind to use the new Red levers, b/c all AXS shifters work with all AXS derailleurs. See here for a compatibility chart: https://www.sram.com/globalassets/document-hierarchy/compatibility-map/road/axs-components-compatibility-map.pdf
Correct, it's just important for Transmission mullet that you use the 47.5mm chainline crank, not a 45mm (for example older Force).
Replaying to my own post: After a few quick reads, these new RED brakes are better performing than previous versions? Adequate power from the hoods? Okay, maybe goodbye, Mullet. It's been fun while it lasted.
Now THAT’s a newsletter! Thanks for the explanation of this industry “inside baseball” as we say in the states. Anybody remember when SRAM was just a twisty shifter on your handle bar?